Formation of Logical Thinking in Senior Preschool Children with Severe Speech Disorders from the Standpoint of the L.M. Vekker’s Information Theory of Mental Development

20

Abstract

Objectives. Contemporary methods of development of logical thinking in preschool children with severe speech disorders (SSD) help to smooth out problems of academic failure at school and social disadaptation. A program for the development of verbal and logical thinking in senior preschool children with SSD was tested. The program was based on the information theory of mental development by L.M. Vekker.

Methods. The implementation of the experimental program for the development of logical thinking included the creation of psychological and pedagogical conditions: modeling of surrounding relationships and processes; consistent introduction of models of different levels of concretization of the abstraction; creation of problem situations between surrounding objects and phenomena. The study involved children with a diagnosis of SSD (7 boys, 2 girls) aged 6 to 7 years (M = 6.5), attending a preschool educational organization. To identify “deficits” of verbal-logical thinking in children with speech disorders, a group of children without speech disorders (4 boys, 5 girls) of the same age (M=6.5) was used. Two measurements were taken — before and after the implementation of the formative program. To diagnose the parameters of verbal logical thinking, the “Methodology for studying the level of children’s readiness for school” by L.A. Yasyukova was used.

Results. Comparison of the indicators of the level of development of thinking in children with speech disorders with the results of children without speech disorders at the first stage of the study showed differences (p≤0.01) in the following parameters: speech and visual classifications, abstract thinking. At the second — developmental — stage, a positive shift at a reliable statistical level occurred in the parameters of the methodology: speech analysis-synthesis (p≤0.05), selection of antonyms (p≤0.05), speech analogies (p≤0.01), speech classifications (p≤0.01), visual analysis synthesis (p≤0.01), visual classifications (p≤0.01).

Conclusions. The results of the study showed that children with speech disorders have learned to use symbolic and speech models to understand logical relationships at the level of visual-effective and visual-figurative thinking. According to the indicator visual analysis-synthesis, children with speech disorders demonstrated results even higher than children without speech disorders. Work is planned to further replenish the children’s vocabulary, to include in the program a set of training in different types of judgments and conclusions.

General Information

Keywords: children with severe speech disorders; development of logical thinking; information theory of mental development by L.M. Vekker; development of mental operations; development of mental behavior; mental modeling; formation of logical thinking

Journal rubric: Education & Intervention Methods

Article type: scientific article

DOI: https://doi.org/10.17759/autdd.2024220301

Acknowledgements. The authors thanks the administrators of the Kindergarten no. 150, Yaroslavl, Marina Mikhailovna Cha rushina and Ekaterina Aleksandrovna Poputyeva, for their help in collecting data for the study.

Received: 08.04.2024

Accepted:

For citation: Simanovskij A.E., Kornienko A.O. Formation of Logical Thinking in Senior Preschool Children with Severe Speech Disorders from the Standpoint of the L.M. Vekker’s Information Theory of Mental Development. Autizm i narusheniya razvitiya = Autism and Developmental Disorders, 2024. Vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 3–10. DOI: 10.17759/autdd.2024220301. (In Russ., аbstr. in Engl.)

Full text

Introduction
According to various authors, the number of speech disorders in preschool children in the Russian Federation ranges from 5.5 to 55.5% [6]. The large data spread can be explained by the difference in the criteria used by the authors when taking into account speech pathology. So, for example, a violation of the pronunciation side of speech in a preschool child, according to the Scientific Research Institute of Hygiene and Health Protection of Children and Adolescents, occurs in 52.5% of cases, and general speech underdevelopment - in only 5.4% of cases [6]. Thus, the more severe the speech disorder, the lower the percentage of children with this type of developmental disorder. Severe speech disorders are often accompanied by cognitive development delays, behavioral disorders, and emotional problems [9; 10; 11]. When speech disorders are combined with intellectual disabilities, learning decreases, and difficulties arise in mastering educational material at school [7]. Due to the mosaic formation of mental operations that ensure verbal and logical thinking, children face difficulties in solving simple mathematical problems, operating with logical and grammatical structures, constructing statements, and formulating conclusions [6].
Often, speech and intelligence disorders may have one common cause - organic disorders that lead to violations of sensorimotor functions and, as a result, to violations of tactile functions and low processing speed of sensory information [16]. These disorders, on the one hand, inhibit the onset of oral speech, on the other hand, inhibits the development of mental operations. The study of the connection of thought processes with social cognition in children with speech disorders shows that insufficient development of thought processes delays the social development of the child [4; 13]. In particular, it turned out that people with intellectual disabilities compete much worse with people with normal intelligence, even in those activities in which they have no deviations from the norm [15]. Hence, it can be concluded that the timely development of intellectual operations in a child should not only increase his learning ability at school, but also affect the effectiveness of social adaptation. At the same time, given that the same brain structures are responsible for logical conclusions and speech behavior, the development of conceptual thinking and logical operations is also simultaneously a process of development of lexical and grammatical structures of speech [13]. This is confirmed in studies that have revealed that the development of cognitive processes, combined with the development of speech skills in preschool age in children with intellectual disabilities, leads to the fact that such children, in the future, do well at school, achieve academic and non-academic achievements, feel confident in social relations [12; 14]. Since children with speech disorders often suffer from basic cognitive functions, such as tactile perception, sensorimotor coordination. nonverbal memory, the development of verbal and logical thinking, is impossible without the development of lower levels of thinking (visually effective and visually figurative). These types of thinking are the basis for the formation of verbal and logical thinking [1]. Studies show that children with speech pathology have difficulty performing tasks to divide a complex picture into parts, they cannot distinguish individual components of a complex image. In general, the thinking of children with speech underdevelopment is characterized by concreteness, infantilism and stereotyping. When completing tasks, children are easily distracted, miss essential points, and cannot adequately assess the situation [3; 4].
In the process of correctional and developmental learning, most often, each cognitive process is isolated and formed separately, and the continuity and general patterns of their formation are not always taken into account [5; 6]. Meanwhile, in L.M. Vekker's information theory, the development of the human cognitive sphere is considered as a single process that naturally reflects the child's transition from sensory-perceptual processes to abstract logical, verbal thinking [2]. An underestimation of continuity in the development of cognitive processes and general patterns can lead to unjustified intellectual delays and a slowdown in the rate of development of the child's psyche.
The purpose of the study
The aim of the study was to develop psychological and pedagogical conditions for the development of verbal and logical thinking in children with severe speech disorders. The psychological and pedagogical conditions were planned to be developed taking into account the information theory of the development of the psyche by L.M. Vekker. Based on these conditions, an experimental program was created for the development of verbal and logical thinking.
Research materials and methods
The methodology of working with children with severe speech disorders was developed on the basis of L.M. Vekker's information theory of mental development. L.M. Vekker considered mental processes as a system of receiving and processing information from the outside world to control human behavior and activity. He believed that the basis of the interaction of the psyche with the outside world is the ability of the psyche to create models of this world. The author also adhered to the idea of active reflection, which allowed the psyche to improve, creating increasingly complex models that reflect the essential properties of surrounding objects and phenomena. In the process of creating increasingly complex models of the surrounding reality, the psyche itself is being improved, gradually moving from simple sensory sensations to the creation of perceptual images and image-representations. The result of the cognitive development of the psyche are complex spatial and temporal models-concepts that are the basis of human conceptual thinking [2, pp. 102-103]. The process of mental complication is continuous and only artificially can separate stages and levels of development be distinguished in it. Already in perceptual images, some mental operations can be detected: the abstraction operation is performed when separating the image of a figure from the background, the analysis operation is performed when selecting individual parts of a perceived object, the synthesis operation is performed when creating an integral image of an object. Such qualities as generality and mediation can be found in image representations, although they have traditionally been attributed only to thought processes [2, p. 89]. This means that different forms of mental reflection can perform the same functions: orientation in the environment and management of behavior and activities on this basis. Simpler forms of reflection cope worse with the tasks of orientation and foresight of the future, more complex ones do it much more effectively. Thus, by helping a child to create and assimilate new forms of reality modeling, teachers and psychologists can develop his psyche. Substitute objects, drawings, graphic schemes, signs, and finally, speech and language can act as such models. This means that there are many possibilities to encode sensory information coming from the outside and, if necessary, if it is impossible to fully use the speech system, other coding and modeling methods available to the child can be used. In this case, the authors used this pattern to work on the development of logical thinking in children with severe speech disorders. It was taken into account that children with this pathology suffer from phonetics, pronunciation, lexical and grammatical structures of speech [3]. Therefore, the emphasis was placed on sensory perception, the creation of kinetic (motor) images that generically reflect the spatial-temporal relationship between phenomena and objects. Such generalized, symbolic actions are the basis for creating visual images, image-representations. In further work, kinetic images can be translated into visual images: drawings and diagrams. When a child becomes able to reproduce speech methods of encoding information, verbal designations and descriptions are added to such visual-figurative, graphical models. That is, the introduction of iconic ways of encoding information for a long time should be combined with visual, graphical models.
The structural unit of logical thinking is judgment. A judgment is a statement or denial expressed in speech form about objects, phenomena, and relationships of the surrounding world. Predicates of judgments are the designation of objects, objects of varying degrees of generality. The judgment can be about a specific object, or about an abstract concept, or its properties.
An essential condition for the development of thinking is the use of semantic context, which is formed in a specific problem situation. A problematic situation sets the direction of mental behavior, helps to determine the purpose of the thought process. Due to the semantic context, the child can correlate the images and models that arise in him with the desired results of thinking, for example, finding adequate means of solving a problem situation [2 p. 125]. Thus, a problematic situation triggers the mechanisms of emotional and motivational regulation of behavior. Therefore, the child begins to perceive mental tasks not as abstract activities, but as interesting situations in which the characters of short stories or fairy tales find themselves who need help.
Thus, on the basis of L.M. Vekker's information theory of mental development, the main psychological and pedagogical conditions for the formation of logical thinking in children with severe speech disorders were formulated:
1. Modeling of surrounding objects, phenomena, relationships, and processes has become the main tool for the development of a child's cognitive processes. Models of varying degrees of complexity were used, from simple kinetic models to complex speech and sign models.
2. Determining the sequence of introducing models of different levels of concretization and on different materials: from concrete object models to kinetic (motor) models, then to drawing and graphic ones. Then sign and speech models are introduced.
3. The condition for starting mental behavior in a child was the creation of problematic situations in which objects of the surrounding world are considered as subjects of fantasy. a fabulous relationship. The problem is most often presented to children as a social conflict between objects (operands). The resolution of such a conflict can occur by finding the necessary action (operator) that resolves the conflict between the specified objects (or their images). Thus, the comparison operation is considered as a search for similar or different features in different objects, a generalization operation, as a grouping of objects based on a similar (family) feature, an abstraction operation, as a selection of one property against the background of all others and a search for objects with the same property. All this can be considered in situations of searching and discovering objects-friends and objects-enemies, collecting objects into a common family, comparing and identifying objects-relatives, determining which property is the main one, what is the cause and what is the consequence. In the course of working with the child, he also developed the ability to use inferences and convey these mental operations in speech form.
The objectives of the program are the formation of mental operations: analysis, synthesis, comparison, generalization, classification, abstraction, concretization, actions by analogy and establishment of cause-and-effect relationships.
Based on the developed psychological and pedagogical conditions, a program for the formation of logical thinking in children with severe speech disorders was created. The program included 26 classes, which were conducted in a subgroup form (6 people each). Each lesson lasted 30 minutes. Group and individual forms of work on assignments were used.
The program was tested on the basis of the Municipal preschool educational institution "Kindergarten No. 150" in Yaroslavl in 2023 (October-December). The study involved 18 children from 6 to 7 years old. Of these, 9 people had severe speech disorders (level 3 ONR).and 9 children were without developmental disorders. To diagnose the level of development of mental operations in the subjects, the "Methods of studying the level of readiness of children to study at school" by L.A. Yasyukova were used. The level of development of the following mental operations was measured: speech analysis-synthesis, speech analogies, speech classifications, visual analysis-synthesis, abstract thinking, antonyms. The comparison between children with and without speech impairments was carried out using the U-Manny-Whitney statistical criterion. A comparison between the indicators of the development of logical operations in a group of children with speech disorders before and after the program was carried out using the T-Wilcoxon criterion.
The results of the study and their discussion
A comparison of the indicators of logical thinking in children with speech disorders and without speech disorders showed that significant differences were found in the following mental operations: speech and visual classifications, abstract thinking (see Table 1)
Table 1
The results of the average values of the diagnosis of thinking processes in normotypic children and children with TNR (n=18)

Indicator

The average values
of children with TNR*

Average values
of children without disabilities

The average value U emp.

Speech analysis-synthesis

2,4

3,0

23

Speech analogies

1,4

2,6

23,5

Speech classifications

2,1

3,4

11,5**

Visualan alysis-synthesis

1,4

1,9

30,5

Visual classifications

2,2

3,6

8**

Abstractthinking

1,8

3,0

9**

Antonyms

 

1,2

1,8

29

Note: *TNR- severe speech disorders
**U emp.<U cr.(p≤0.01)
The indicator "speech classifications" indicates a low level of children with speech disorders to select a generalizing word and select words from the same categorical group.
The indicator "visual classifications" indicates a low level of the ability of children with speech disorders to identify common visual signs in the objects depicted in the picture, to combine objects on a common basis.
The indicator "abstract thinking" shows the weak ability of children with speech disorders to correlate the numerical value and the number of objects drawn, to highlight the number of letters in a word and abstract from the meaning of this word, to find the functional meaning of objects and search for objects that are opposite in functional meaning.
The reasons for these features, in addition to the low level of development of mental operations, were: a small lexical stock that does not allow finding a word from the same categorical group and a generalization word, as well as a low ability to draw conclusions and convey causal relationships in speech form.
After the experimental program, a re-diagnosis of children with severe speech disorders was carried out. The results of the statistical comparison are shown in Table 2.
Table 2
The results of the average values of the diagnosis of thinking processes in children with TNR at the beginning and end of the program (n=9)

Indicator

The average value for children with TNR* at the beginning of work

The average value for children with TNR* at the end of work

The average value Т emp.

Speechanalysis-synthesis

2,4

3,3

6**

Speechanalogies

1,4

3,2

1***

Speechclassifications

2,1

3,2

3***

Visualanalysis-synthesis

1,4

2,8

3***

Visualclassifications

2,2

3,4

3***

Abstractthinking

1,8

2,4

10

Antonyms

 

1,2

2,0

6**

Note: *TNR- severe speech disorders **Тemp.<Тcr.. (p≤0.05) ***Т emp.<Тcr.. (p≤0.01)
The results of the study showed that changes in the level of development of mental operations in children with speech disorders occurred in all compared indicators. A significant shift was observed in the following mental operations: speech analysis-synthesis, speech analogies, speech classifications, visual analysis-synthesis, visual classifications, antonyms. Only in terms of abstract thinking, the differences between the indicators did not reach a criterion value.
Thus, the program of work with children with speech disorders has shown its effectiveness, and the psychological and pedagogical conditions have shown their effectiveness. In the future, it is planned to introduce children to different types of judgments and conclusions, replenish their speech stock, and teach them to convey different types of relationships in speech: equivalence, intersection, subordination, subordination, opposites, contradictions.
Conclusions

Thus, the selected psychological and pedagogical conditions and the experimental program created on their basis have shown their effectiveness. L.M. Vekker's theory proved useful for creating the following psychological and pedagogical conditions:

  1. Using the modeling method as the main tool for the development of logical thinking.
  2. The need to begin the development of logical thinking on the subject-effective material, gradually moving to more general and abstract forms of modeling relations between objects and objects of the surrounding world.
  3. The condition for starting mental behavior in a child was the creation of problematic situations in which objects of the surrounding world are considered as subjects of fantasy. a fabulous relationship. The problem is most often presented to children as a social conflict between objects (operands). The resolution of such a conflict can occur by finding the necessary action (operator) that resolves the conflict between the specified objects (or their images).

References

  1. Beloshistaya A.V. Razvitie logicheskogo myshleniya u doshkol’nikov na verbal’nom materiale: [Okonchanie]  [Development of logical thinking in preschool children on verbal material: End]. Doshkol’noevospitanie = Preschool  Education, 2019, no. 6, pp. 17—22. (In Russ., abstr. in Engl.) 
  2. Vekker L.M. Psikhikaireal’nost’: Edinaya teoriya psikhicheskikh protsessov [Psyche and reality: A unified theory of  psychological processes]. Moscow: Publ. Smysl, 1998. 679 p. ISBN 5-89357-041-3. 
  3. Davydova V.S., Datskova E.A. Osobennosti razvitiya u shkol’nikov s TNR logicheskogo myshleniya [Specifics of logical  thinking development in school students with severe developmental disorders]. In Sovremennoe obrazovanie: aktual’nye  voprosy teorii i praktiki: sbornik statei III Mezhdunarodnoi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii (Penza, 30 maya 2022 g.)  [Education today: current topics of research and practice: Proceedings of the 3rd research-to- practice conference (Penza,  30 May 2022)]. Penza: Publ. Nauka i Prosveshchenie, 2022. Pp. 73—75. ISBN 978-5-00173-349-2. 
  4. Karpenko E.S. Osobennosti razvitiya poznavatel’nykh protsessov u detei s rechevymi narusheniyami i puti korrektsii  [Features of the Development of Cognitive Processes in Children with Speech Disorders and the Ways of Their Remedy].  Vestnik BGU: Obrazovanie: Lichnost’: Obshchestvo = BSU bulletin: Education: Personality: Society, 2022, no. 2, pp. 35—41.  DOI:10.18101/2307-3330-2022-2-35-41 
  5. Novak O.V. Razvitie logicheskogo myshleniya u doshkol’nikov [Logical thinking development in preschoolers].  Obrazovanie i vospitanie = Education and Upbringing, 2019, no. 5, pp. 15—18. 
  6. Nol’d N.V., Skochilov R.V., Berezina T.N. et al. Osobennosti struktury intellektual’nogo razvitiya detei doshkol’nogo i  mladshego shkol’nogo vozrasta s obshchim nedorazvitiem rechi [Features of the structure of intellectual development for  preschool and primary school children with expressive language disorder (general speech underdevelopment)]. Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta: Psikhologiya = Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University: Psychology, 2020, vol. 10, no. 4,  pp. 428—441. DOI:10.21638/spbu16.2020.404 
  7. Semenova M.S. Osobennosti razvitiya myslitel’nykh operatsii mladshikh shkol’nikov s obshchim nedorazvitiem rechi  [Features of the Development of Thinking Operations of Younger Schools with a General Speech Underdevelopment]. In  Vserossiiskii issledovatel’skii forum studentov i uchashchikhsya: Sbornik statei III Vserossiiskoi nauchno-prakticheskoi  konferentsii (Petrozavodsk, 27 maya 2021 g.) [All-Russian Research Forum for Students: Proceedings of the 3rd All Russian research-to-practice conference (Petrozavodsk, 27 May 2021)]. Petrozavodsk: Publ. Novaya Nauka, 2021.  Pp. 305—311. ISBN 978-5-00174-255-5. 
  8. Yasyukova L.A. Metodika opredeleniya gotovnosti k shkole: Prognoz i profilaktika problem obucheniya v nachal’noi  shkole: Metodicheskoe rukovodstvo: Ch. 1 [Methods for assessing school readiness: Predicting and preventing education  problems in elementary school: Guidelines: Pt. 1] / Rosstandart. 6th ed., corrected and appended. Saint Petersburg: Publ.  IMATON, 2020. 223 p. ISBN 978-5-7822-0107-4. 
  9. Feldman H.M. How Young Children Learn Language and Speech. Pediatrics in Review, 2019, vol. 40, no. 8, pp. 398—411.  DOI:10.1542/pir.2017-0325 
  10. Jin F., Schjolberg S., Eadie P. et al. The association of cognitive abilities with language disorder in 8-year-old children:  A population-based clinical sample. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders, 2023, vol. 58, no. 4,  pp. 1268—1285. DOI:10.1111/1460-6984.12861 
  11. Larson C., Mathée-Scott J., Kaplan D. et al. Cognitive processes associated with working memory in children with  developmental language disorder. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 2023, vol. 234, article no. 105709. 47 p.  DOI:10.1016/j.jecp.2023.105709 
  12. Nursanti R.R., Purbani W. A Deep Scanning on Mild Mental Retardation Individual’s Language Acquisition and  Development. VELES: Voices of English Language Education Society, 2022, vol. 6, no. 2, pp. 453—465. DOI:10.29408/veles.v6i2.5223 
  13. Oesch N. Social Brain Perspectives on the Social and Evolutionary Neuroscience of Human Language. Brain Sciences,  2024, vol. 14, no. 2, articleno. 166. 24 p. DOI:10.3390/brainsci14020166 
  14. Park J., Miller C.A., Sanjeevan T. et al. Non-linguistic cognitive measures as predictors of functionally defined developmental  language disorder in monolingual and bilingual children. International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders,  2021, vol. 56, no. 4, pp. 858—872. DOI:10.1111/1460-6984.12632 
  15. Sakalidis K.E., Menting S.G.P., Hettinga F.J. The Role of Cognition and Social Factors in Competition: How Do People  with Intellectual Disabilities Respond to Opponents? International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,  2023, vol. 20, no. 3, article no. 2670. 14 p. DOI:10.3390/ijerph20032670 
  16. Tseng Y.T., Hsu H.J. Not only motor skill performance but also haptic function is impaired in children with developmental  language disorder. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 2023, vol. 134, article no. 104412. 12 p. DOI:10.1016/j.ridd.2022.104412 

Information About the Authors

Andrej E. Simanovskij, PhD in Psychology, Associate Professor, Head of the Department of Special (Correctional) Pedagogy of the Faculty of defectology, Yaroslavl State Pedagogical University named after K.D. Ushinsky, Yaroslavl, Russia, ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8294-4915, e-mail: simanovsky@yandex.ru

Anna O. Kornienko, teacher, Kindergarten no. 150, Yaroslavl, Russia, ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-9510-7758

Metrics

Views

Total: 43
Previous month: 5
Current month: 38

Downloads

Total: 20
Previous month: 7
Current month: 13